The number of minors involved in child labor violations in the United States more than tripled from 2017 to 2025. Compounding this issue, several state legislatures have recently weakened child labor protection laws. A key component of these laws is whether employers are required to obtain an employment certificate when hiring minors under 18 years of age, which typically requires a parent’s signature and is issued by a school. Proponents of loosening child labor regulations argue that there is a lack of evidence demonstrating the effectiveness of these laws in reducing child labor violations. In this study, we examine the effect of state-mandated employment certificates on reducing child labor violations. We find that the requirement leads to an average of 13.3% fewer violation cases (not statistically significant), 31.8% fewer minors involved in child labor violations, and 34.9% lower civil penalties per minor, indicating reduced severity of violations that do occur. The negative effects on the number of cases and minors persist after addressing endogeneity concerns, as assessed using two novel instrumental variables. Furthermore, we find a positive relationship between the number of unaccompanied migrant children released to a state and the incidence and severity of child labor violations, suggesting that this demographic is particularly vulnerable to labor exploitation. We identify two key mechanisms driving the effectiveness of employment certificates. First, they act as a legal deterrent for employers, as the documented acknowledgment of regulations makes it more difficult to claim ignorance. This is reflected in the higher rate of violations categorized as “willful” in certificate-mandate states. Second, they enhance stakeholder awareness and monitoring. Compliance improves for requirements explicitly documented in the certificates but not for those less visible. Moreover, among common certificate features, parental consent shows the strongest protective effect, suggesting the importance of active oversight and awareness. To our knowledge, this study is the first to provide quantitative evidence for the efficacy of mandating employment certificates in reducing child labor violations. It highlights the critical role of state policies in protecting minor workers and aims to enrich the discourse on child labor regulation and policy implementation.
← 返回列表
EXPRESS: The Effect of State-Mandated Employment Certificates on Child Labor Violations in the United States
Production and Operations Management · Jiacong (Fred) Bao, Ashish Kabra
methodmethod/causal-inferencemethod/empiricalsustainabilitysustainability/esg
摘要
本研究考察了美国州级强制就业证书要求对减少童工违规行为的影响。通过工具变量等方法分析,发现该要求虽未显著降低违规案件数量,但使涉及的未成年人数量减少31.8%,且每名未成年人的民事罚款降低34.9%,表明违规严重性下降。研究还识别了法律威慑和利益相关者监督两个关键机制,其中父母同意条款的保护作用最强。